Comments on: OpenID Thoughts http://itickr.com/?p=119 Tracking Identity Sun, 31 Jan 2010 05:06:28 -0600 http://wordpress.org/?v=2.8.5 hourly 1 By: In Context » Life before you have a selector http://itickr.com/?p=119&cpage=1#comment-2229 In Context » Life before you have a selector Thu, 09 Jul 2009 00:54:55 +0000 http://itickr.com/?p=119#comment-2229 [...] an OpenID NASCAR (NASCAR) like this (courtesy of JanRain’s very cool [...] [...] an OpenID NASCAR (NASCAR) like this (courtesy of JanRain’s very cool [...]

]]> By: itickr.com » OpenID Nascarization http://itickr.com/?p=119&cpage=1#comment-1449 itickr.com » OpenID Nascarization Tue, 07 Apr 2009 16:37:23 +0000 http://itickr.com/?p=119#comment-1449 [...] raised the issue of Nascarization more than an year ago . There should be one OpenID button. Not two. Not three. Else it’s not scalable for the [...] [...] raised the issue of Nascarization more than an year ago . There should be one OpenID button. Not two. Not three. Else it’s not scalable for the [...]

]]> By: Who is Hahleq : No true identity, Open or otherwise, in sight http://itickr.com/?p=119&cpage=1#comment-1127 Who is Hahleq : No true identity, Open or otherwise, in sight Mon, 19 May 2008 20:24:51 +0000 http://itickr.com/?p=119#comment-1127 [...] Wow! about 5 minutes after initially posting this, I ran across this blog entry by Ashish Jain.  Great stuff and cuts to the heart of my point.  Also very troubling as Ashish is [...] [...] Wow! about 5 minutes after initially posting this, I ran across this blog entry by Ashish Jain.  Great stuff and cuts to the heart of my point.  Also very troubling as Ashish is [...]

]]> By: peter http://itickr.com/?p=119&cpage=1#comment-1062 peter Sun, 13 Apr 2008 22:54:40 +0000 http://itickr.com/?p=119#comment-1062 could not leave openid authenticated comment. On SignOn.com, could not get UI to recognize my cardspace card (on vista buseinss SP1). could not leave openid authenticated comment. On SignOn.com, could not get UI to recognize my cardspace card (on vista buseinss SP1).

]]> By: Steven Osborn » Blog Archive » One Button to Rule them all. http://itickr.com/?p=119&cpage=1#comment-986 Steven Osborn » Blog Archive » One Button to Rule them all. Mon, 31 Mar 2008 23:42:24 +0000 http://itickr.com/?p=119#comment-986 [...] have been quite a bit of talk about the current state of OpenID login screens that are becoming cluttered with [...] [...] have been quite a bit of talk about the current state of OpenID login screens that are becoming cluttered with [...]

]]> By: Ashish Jain http://itickr.com/?p=119&cpage=1#comment-983 Ashish Jain Sun, 30 Mar 2008 22:15:03 +0000 http://itickr.com/?p=119#comment-983 Ryan, The issues that you have raised in your referenced blog post are more around CardSpace. I agree with your perspective (listed my own at http://itickr.com/?p=82). However, I believe that the issues with CardSpace are mainly implementation specific. However, the issues around OpenID are more foundational. Thanks, - Ashish Ryan,
The issues that you have raised in your referenced blog post are more around CardSpace. I agree with your perspective (listed my own at http://itickr.com/?p=82).
However, I believe that the issues with CardSpace are mainly implementation specific. However, the issues around OpenID are more foundational.
Thanks,
- Ashish

]]> By: Ryan Janssen http://itickr.com/?p=119&cpage=1#comment-982 Ryan Janssen Sun, 30 Mar 2008 20:40:14 +0000 http://itickr.com/?p=119#comment-982 Ashish, I just finished a 3 part blog post at http://drstarcat.com that ended with a discussion of the UI (http://drstarcat.com/archives/30). Very good questions you raise. Ashish, I just finished a 3 part blog post at http://drstarcat.com that ended with a discussion of the UI (http://drstarcat.com/archives/30). Very good questions you raise.

]]> By: Ashish Jain http://itickr.com/?p=119&cpage=1#comment-959 Ashish Jain Sat, 22 Mar 2008 02:33:38 +0000 http://itickr.com/?p=119#comment-959 Hahleq, Security and Convenience don't go very well together. I would imagine that soon OpenID will come to a resting state where it finds the most adoption and then focus on that need. - Ashish Hahleq,
Security and Convenience don’t go very well together. I would imagine that soon OpenID will come to a resting state where it finds the most adoption and then focus on that need.
- Ashish

]]> By: Ashish Jain http://itickr.com/?p=119&cpage=1#comment-958 Ashish Jain Sat, 22 Mar 2008 02:30:02 +0000 http://itickr.com/?p=119#comment-958 Peter, I get what you are doing and it's definitely innovative. I just find it a bit hard to scale from an adoption perspective. Having a client side solution with a service in the cloud for syncing is probably another route to look at. - Ashish Peter,
I get what you are doing and it’s definitely innovative. I just find it a bit hard to scale from an adoption perspective. Having a client side solution with a service in the cloud for syncing is probably another route to look at.
- Ashish

]]> By: Who Is Hahleq? http://itickr.com/?p=119&cpage=1#comment-939 Who Is Hahleq? Tue, 18 Mar 2008 02:52:20 +0000 http://itickr.com/?p=119#comment-939 Great post and nice feedback from Peter. I think I get what ClickPass is doing, but even as an advocate for where OpenID is heading, as a security geek, my conerns remain high. I have enough problems with OpenID security without it also becoming a "single click". I know ease-of-use is a cornerstone of what we are all aiming for, but given the current state of OpenID insecurity, do we really want this level of complete transparency? I for one, know I do not. As implemented toay I use OpenID to play around with different feature sets from the various OPs and then only at sites that if compromised, really wouldn't impact me. Believe me, I want to use OpenID everywhere and for everything, but until implemented in a manner with real security, as a user, I'm staying on the sideline. Certainly, the "Nascar-ization" issue and some folks turning their credentials into OpenIDs, but not then accepting other OpenIDs are also a real kick in the shins of progress. I know that OpenID isn't intended to be THE complete identity answer, but as I mentioned on my blog today before seeing this, we need something truly useful sooner than later. By truly useful, I mean something that hits on more of Kim Cameron's 7 Laws than we've gotten today. On the sideline cheering, but contemplating where to get back in the game, - Hahleq Great post and nice feedback from Peter. I think I get what ClickPass is doing, but even as an advocate for where OpenID is heading, as a security geek, my conerns remain high. I have enough problems with OpenID security without it also becoming a “single click”. I know ease-of-use is a cornerstone of what we are all aiming for, but given the current state of OpenID insecurity, do we really want this level of complete transparency? I for one, know I do not.

As implemented toay I use OpenID to play around with different feature sets from the various OPs and then only at sites that if compromised, really wouldn’t impact me. Believe me, I want to use OpenID everywhere and for everything, but until implemented in a manner with real security, as a user, I’m staying on the sideline.

Certainly, the “Nascar-ization” issue and some folks turning their credentials into OpenIDs, but not then accepting other OpenIDs are also a real kick in the shins of progress. I know that OpenID isn’t intended to be THE complete identity answer, but as I mentioned on my blog today before seeing this, we need something truly useful sooner than later. By truly useful, I mean something that hits on more of Kim Cameron’s 7 Laws than we’ve gotten today.

On the sideline cheering, but contemplating where to get back in the game,
- Hahleq

]]>